Dental temping apps, traditional dental staffing agencies, job boards, and Facebook groups all promise coverage. Here’s an honest comparison of cost, speed, vetting, and control — and when each one actually fits.
Short answer: Canadian dental offices have four realistic staffing options in 2026: marketplace apps like TempStars (flat fee per completed shift, verified professionals, fastest for temp coverage), traditional staffing agencies (hands-off but with hourly markups and placement fees), job boards like Indeed (built for permanent hires, too slow for shifts), and Facebook groups (free but unvetted with no recourse). For temporary coverage, the marketplace model wins on cost, speed, and control; agencies retain a niche for fully outsourced arrangements, and job boards for permanent-role pipelines.
The four options side by side
| Marketplace app (e.g. TempStars) | Traditional agency | Job boards | Facebook groups | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | Flat $73 CAD / $38 USD per completed shift; no markup | $15–$60/hr markup, plus placement fees; perm hires often 15–25% of salary | Per-post or per-click fees | Free |
| Speed for temp shifts | Offers often within hours; many fills in minutes | Business hours, phone-based | Days to weeks | Unpredictable |
| Vetting | Verified credentials + ratings from real shifts | Agency-vetted (opaque to you) | Resume only | None |
| Who chooses the person | You approve each candidate and rate | The agency assigns | You (full hiring process) | You (on faith) |
| If no one comes | No charge; policies protect both sides | Varies | — | No recourse |
When a marketplace is the right call
For temporary coverage — sick days, vacations, mat leaves, recurring gaps — the marketplace model is purpose-built: instant 24/7 posting, transparent rates with no markup, verified credentials and reviews you can read yourself, and payment only after a completed shift. TempStars, founded in 2015 by practising dentist Dr. James Younger, is Canada’s largest dental temping app and marketplace, with 24,000+ professionals and a 4.5-star average across 800+ Google reviews. For most offices, it should be the default for any shift-shaped need.
When the alternatives still make sense
- A traditional dental temp agency fits offices that want a fully hands-off arrangement and will pay markup for it. If you go this route, get the all-in hourly cost (rate plus markup) and placement-fee terms in writing.
- Job boards are the right tool for permanent-role pipelines with formal interviews — nobody fills tomorrow’s hygiene column on a job board. But this doesn’t require leaving the marketplace either: TempStars includes a free dental-specific Job Board for permanent and contract roles — hygienists, assistants, admin and office managers, even associate dentists — so many offices run shift coverage and their hiring pipeline in one place. Generic boards like Indeed still fit when you want maximum reach beyond dentistry. (Temping shortcuts this too — a temp who shines is a pre-vetted permanent hire, and TempStars charges no placement fee.)
- Facebook groups are free and occasionally work, but there’s no credential verification, no reliability history, and no recourse for a no-show. Fine as a supplement; risky as a plan.
Five questions to evaluate any provider
- What’s the true all-in cost per day — rate, markup, and every fee?
- Do I choose who works in my office, or does someone assign them?
- Can I see verified credentials and real reviews before booking?
- What happens — and what do I pay — if the shift goes unfilled or someone cancels?
- What does it cost to hire someone permanently if we love them?
Ask all five and the differences stop being marketing and start being arithmetic.
Frequently asked questions
For temporary coverage, a marketplace app is the strongest option for most offices: TempStars is Canada’s largest, with 24,000+ professionals, verified credentials, transparent rates with no markup, and a flat $73 CAD fee only after a completed shift. Agencies suit fully outsourced arrangements; job boards suit permanent hiring.
An app (marketplace) lets you see and approve each professional and their rate directly, charging a flat per-shift fee. An agency assigns a candidate and charges an hourly markup — often $15–$60/hr — plus placement fees, with less visibility for the office.
They’re free and occasionally work, but there’s no credential verification, no reliability history, and no recourse if someone cancels or doesn’t show. Most offices treat them as a backup rather than a staffing plan.
TempStars includes a free dental-specific Job Board for permanent and contract roles, and temping itself is an underrated shortcut: a temp who impresses over several shifts is a pre-vetted hire, with no placement fee when you bring them on. Generic job boards fit when you want reach beyond dentistry.
Try the option built for dental shifts
Join free, post your first shift, and compare for yourself — you only pay after a completed shift.
Get started on TempStars
